Which server is suitable for which project?

More and more individuals and businesses now prefer their own server over shared web hosting even for a single website. The reasons for this trend are diverse and include greater flexibility, excellent scalability, and notably reduced costs in recent years. However, to utilise an optimal and efficient environment, it is essential to make an ideal choice for each project and strategically leverage the benefits offered by a dedicated server, cloud server, or Virtual Private Server (VPS hosting, VPS). Despite having the same operating system and the scalability options provided by a web provider, each of these options has distinct features.

What are the general characteristics important in a server?

Servers use various components as hardware and, just like desktop PCs or laptops, differ significantly in their performance. Ultimately, behind every IT infrastructure lies a dedicated server, which can operate as a single unit, serve as a host for numerous VPS hosting instances, or work with other instances in a compute cluster to form a decentralized cloud server. Some key parameters are identical for all three server types and are used as a benchmark for performance and other relevant characteristics:

• Number and possibly clock speed of virtual or physical CPU cores
• Size of permanent and, if offered, temporary RAM as memory
• Type (SSD, HDD) and capacity of the provided drives
• Location and bandwidth of the connection to global internet nodes
• Amount of guaranteed data volume (traffic) in the contract and billing method
• Scalability during server setup and possible expansion afterwards
• Permanent or temporary availability and guaranteed maximum downtime
• Additional extras like backups, technical support, or administration tools such as Plesk or DirectAdmin

These details primarily serve to provide an overview of the conditions by which a dedicated server, VPS hosting, or cloud server can be compared among themselves or between individual offerings within a category.

What are the specific features of a dedicated server, VPS hosting, or cloud server?

A dedicated server represents a traditional and classic computer system with its own hardware exclusively provided to the customer. This means that with proper configuration and appropriate scaling, it offers exceptionally high stability and security because only the user's services run on it. At the same time, with proper scaling, it maintains consistently high performance reserves because they are permanently available. For web hosting of a larger company or an online shop, as well as a sophisticated web service, a dedicated server often provides excellent conditions and has been considered a standard for more than three decades.

The VPS hosting has established itself as a cost-effective alternative since the mid-2000s, allowing a dedicated server to be replaced without restrictions on areas such as individual configuration limiting flexibility. It is a completely virtualised server or an independent instance with its own operating system under a shared kernel. This concept offers advantages such as very low costs with full flexibility and high scalability, but also disadvantages such as collectively shared and resource-limited hardware, which can affect performance when multiple vServers are fully utilised in parallel.

The Cloud Servers represent the latest development and share some characteristics with a vServer. However, they do not rely on a single dedicated server for resources but are connected to clustered computing networks. This allows them to largely abstract the server from its physical environment, providing extremely high performance, for example, for peak loads almost in real-time, and ensuring that failures of important components do not affect availability. Companies prefer Cloud Servers for mission-critical applications or a compute-intensive web service such as Software as a Service (SaaS) or outsourcing powerful hardware that is only temporarily used.

What are the key criteria for choosing the type of server?

Determining which type of server best meets the requirements for a planned or existing project must be assessed in each individual case based on several relevant criteria. The decision should always be made after a thorough consideration of the pros and cons, as migrating to a different server later on involves a significant amount of time and effort. The key criteria that must be taken into account include:

• Reliability and Stability: If even a brief outage, such as in an online shop, results in financial risks or loss of revenue, maintaining constant availability and low Server Response Time (SRT) is crucial. In this aspect, a dedicated server or a cloud server offer advantages over a virtual server.
• Spontaneous and Continuous Performance: Ensuring resources are always available for sudden spikes in traffic, such as numerous simultaneous requests in web hosting, is essential to avoid issues like slow page loading or even errors like HTTP Error 504 Gateway Timeout. Some cloud servers can provide almost unlimited performance, but this can also lead to unexpected costs as billing is often based on actual usage. Therefore, it is important to balance risks, benefits, and requirements to determine the optimal server.

• Availability and Temporary Usage: A dedicated server and a VPS hosting server are designed for 24/7/365 operation. However, in certain situations, a server may only need to perform at specific times, such as providing a web service during working hours. Cloud servers prove advantageous in such cases as they allow real-time scalability. They also have the lowest downtime, but can be more expensive than dedicated servers or VPS hosting servers when consistently under high load.

• Long-Term Scalability: Sometimes, a small, seemingly insignificant project can evolve into a highly visited website due to high demand, requiring a more powerful infrastructure. Migrating from a Dedicated Server to another one requires technical knowledge and proves to be time-consuming and costly. Cloud Servers and VPS hosting, on the other hand, can be easily scaled afterwards, giving them an advantage in projects with uncertain demand.

• Performance and Response Times: When a server provides a system- or security-critical web service, it absolutely needs high performance with minimal Server Response Time (SRT). This also benefits commercially used websites by speeding up the loading times. For non-time-critical services like email or transferring large files, VPS hosting provides optimal conditions with an unbeatable cost-benefit ratio.

Which Server is Ideal for a Specific Project?

To individually determine the perfect server for a specific situation, the key criteria should be prioritised so that a solution combines the most advantages with minimal disadvantages.

However, in general, a Dedicated Server is optimal for projects that require high security and stability with long-term planning and solid financing. This includes web hosting for a larger online shop or a popular website with many concurrent visitors during peak times.

A VPS hosting is ideal for businesses with higher risk such as a new online shop, an independent provider of services or digital products, or a website that is still building its audience. Additionally, it is excellent for a non-time-critical web service like email or FTP.

Cloud Servers are extremely flexible and scalable and are generally suitable for most tasks, although depending on the purpose, one should pay attention to billing based on fixed time intervals or actual required performance. However, they are often more expensive than comparable VPS hosting solutions and demonstrate their strengths primarily in computationally intensive and complex use cases - such as serving as a customer-oriented SaaS solutions, migrating parts of an IT infrastructure to the cloud, or combining demanding web hosting with additional services like email, FTP, development environments (IDE), or custom runtime environments for source code.

Tip: Some specialised server systems are also required for certain specific use cases. For example, MacOS Server for applications from the Apple universe or GPU Servers for applications in the field of artificial intelligence.

Image credit: Gerd Altmann on Pixabay